Find cheap car insurance by quickly comparing up to quotes for free. auto insurance companies in America to get you the lowest insurance prices available . Geico was the second cheapest car insurance company we found for one of the most expensive in ourysis of the largest car insurance . Ways to Get the Cheapest Car Insurance Rates Possible. Don t assume any one company is the cheapest. Don t ignore local and regional insurers. Ask about discounts. Pay your bills on time. Check insurance costs when buying a car. Skip comprehensive and collision coverage for an older car. Raise your deductible. . How to find good, cheap car insurance. Use an auto insurance comparison website to compare quotes. Understand the factors that affect your insurance rates. Think about lowering your deductible. If you have an older vehicle, consider skipping comprehensive and collision coverage. Claim your discounts. Consider third .